Definition: Then came the disciples to Jesus apart, and said, Why could not we cast him out?

Explanation: Okay, let’s break down this verse from Matthew 17:19. It's a really interesting and slightly unsettling part of the story! Here’s what it means in simple terms: The Situation: Jesus is teaching a group of twelve men – his closest followers – and they are feeling frustrated. They want to do something that would be incredibly disrespectful, which is to throw him out. What's Happening: They’re arguing about whether it's right to break a rule or tradition. It’s like they’re wrestling with the idea of defying Jesus. The Key Phrase: "Why could not we cast him out?" – This is the core of the verse. It’s asking, “Why would we not do something that would be clearly wrong and disrespectful?” What it Suggests: It’s suggesting a deep conflict within the group. They're grappling with a difficult decision, and the argument highlights their disagreement about what is acceptable behavior. Overall Meaning: The verse speaks to the tension between following tradition and challenging authority – a classic biblical struggle! It shows that even people who believe deeply in something can have disagreements about how to act. Important Note: This passage is often interpreted as a sign of doubt or questioning within Jesus’ followers, but it's more complex than just simple disagreement. It also hints at the possibility of Jesus being tested and challenged by his disciples. Do you want me to: Explain another verse? Discuss the context of this passage in more detail?